Video and Photos for Victoria (V.E.) Schwab’s Tolkien Lecture 17 Replies We were blessed to have Victoria Schwab visit Pembroke on May Day, and deliver the sixth Tolkien lecture, titled ‘In Search of Doors’. A few photos from the event: Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:Like Loading...
Well, having listened to her talk, I would be very happy to sell everything I own to study for an MFA with V.E. as the mentor or faculty member. I am awed.
Would you be so kind to put up all the question and answer portion in writing? Thank you!
Wonderful! Would love a hard copy…
My first reaction on listening to the lecture was an inclination to dislike Victoria Schwab. It reminded me of a story that Victoria Coren-Mitchell tells of accompanying someone to a literary conference in the University States who began his lecture in exactly the same way. Coren-Mitchell tells of her desire for hide, one that grew as the hostility of the audience grew. I hope that Schwab was more gently treated. But it soon became clear that she was respectful of your lecture series. I can never be angry with someone who learned a love of reading through Harry Potter. This was also my daughters’ experience and in reading the early books aloud to them I learned to love them too. It was a moment of sadness when they decided to read the later books for themselves and dispensed of my services. I still miss that experience today.
The other reflection that changed my mind was the realisation that Tolkien and (explicitly) Lewis would have agreed with her too. Lewis, in particular, disapproved of a literary canon that a child “ought” to read and to love. He wanted a truthful response to a book whether it was pleasure in reading a comic or dislike of a so-called “classic”. I hope that neither of them would want their work to become canonical although I am sure that both of them would hope that eventually Schwab would read it and grow to love it. What writer desires otherwise?
Thank you for posting this. I hope that I might be able to attend a lecture in the series in future. I have friends and family in Oxford with whom I know I could stay.
Lots of good stuff here in this warm-hearted, accessible lecture that I’m sure will be inspiring to many a fledgling writer. I don’t agree with her dismissal of Tolkien – it’s good to be familiar with the tradition you’re stepping into – although admittedly the notion of someone else’s ‘must reads’ can be irritating, and the canon should be challenged. However, I do agree with her main message – that you have to find your own door, and the voices of the fringes need to be heard. Thank you Victoria, for the honest advice, and for the organisers for sharing this.
Pingback: In Books and Other Things // Mar-Apr – THE SWASHBUCKLER
Pingback: Friday Finds: May 11, 2018 — @TLT16 Teen Librarian Toolbox
Pingback: All the shades of magic in Oxford – MindforBooks
Reblogged this on Die Wortspielerin and commented:
Victoria “V.E.” Schwab, unter anderem für ihre Weltenwanderer-Trilogie bekannt, hat die diesjährige inzwischen schon sechste “Tolkien Lecture” am Pembroke College gehalten, und wenn ihr ein Stündchen Zeit habt, solltet ihr euch das nicht entgehen lassen …
Pingback: News & Notes – 6/09/2018 – The Bookwyrm’s Hoard
Pingback: Book Recommendation of the Week | Ryan Yarber
Pingback: Writing Tips: 6 Things To Consider Before Writing A Novel | The Creative Penn
Pingback: Writing Tips: 6 Things To Consider Before Writing A Novel | rogerpseudonym
Pingback: Litterære links #5: “I really wanted a to see a brown girl on these covers. And I wanted her in a position of power.” – Windblown Pages
Pingback: The Tamar Valley Writers Festival – Heather Ewings
Pingback: On J.R.R. Tolkien | Ryan Yarber
Pingback: Announcement: Tolkien Symposium on Fantasy Literature, May 16, 2020 | The J.R.R. Tolkien Lecture on Fantasy Literature